North America

USA - New York

New York
New York
275 Seventh Ave, Suite 706
New York, NY 10001
P: +1.646.722.3041
newyork@prime-research.com

USA - Detroit/ Ann Arbor

Ann Arbor / Detroit
Ann Arbor/ Detroit
309 Maynard Street
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
+1 734 913 0348
annarbor@prime-research.com

Europe

Germany

Frankfurt / Mainz
Kaiserstrasse 22-24
55116 Mainz
+49 6131 2180 0
mainz@prime-research.com

United Kingdom

Oxford
58 St. Aldates
Oxford, OX1 1ST
+44 1865 324 911
oxford@prime-research.com

Switzerland

Zurich
Badenerstraße 549
8048 Zurich
+41 43 210 97 46
zurich@prime-research.com

South America

Brazil

Sao Paulo
Av. Roque Petroni Júnior, 1089
São Paulo, SP Brasil – 04707-900
+55 11 3033 5858
saopaulo@prime-research.com

Asia Pacific

China

Shanghai
Rm.306, Bldg. 2
Lujiazui Software Park No. 100, Lane 91, E'shan Rd. Pudong Shanghai 200127, China
+86 21 6859 2099
shanghai@prime-research.com

India

Office no. 3, 14th floor German Center
Building No. 9B -DLF Cyber City
Phase-III Gurgaon - INDIA
+91 124 463 6045
newdelhi@prime-research.com

Is the Influencer Marketing Bubble about to Crash Down to Earth?

Posted On August 07, 2018

It is a fair question. Recent news on the topic have caused quite a stir in the digital world so the value of influencer marketing is under scrutiny. I recently reviewed the matter in a Twitter chat with various practitioners. CIPR board and council member Ella Minty started the debate: Is the influencer marketing bubble actually about to burst?

Let’s rewind a little bit. The influencer marketing discipline has been going through a lot recently. The recent Paul Logan case raised deep concerns towards ‘brand safety’. In the background, criticism about fake followers was rumbling while social media audiences have been asking for higher ethic standards and transparency from online ambassadors. In addition to this, a completely new form of influencers, Computer Generated Influencers (CGI), have emerged and reshaped the image of online authenticity. Within a short period of time, brand and creator content have dramatically evolved.

However, it has to be said that the influencer marketing backlash is beneficial for the discipline as there’s plenty of room for improvement. Its main activity revolves around relationship building and places the role of PR at a central place. If the discipline doesn’t address the issues around the perception of lack of regulation, transparency and authenticity, audiences will ultimately move away from those platforms.

So, how are brands adapting to those changes? They are taking action. Unilever has recently expressed its will to improve the integrity and transparency of influencer marketing and tackle influencer fraud. Elsewhere, the Body Shop is capitalizing on its digital network more than ever to drive social change and sell its product by refining their selection criteria when it comes to working with influencers: “We have very strict criteria when it comes to working with influencers to promote our brands or social causes. We always say it’s not just about another pretty face it’s about finding someone who stands for something” explained Charlotte Amouy Adjchavanich, Body Shop Integrated International Brand Communications Director.

To help us understand those changes, Scott Guthrie, strategic advisor at CampaignDeus, shared his thoughts about the state of the industry: “Is the influencer marketing bubble about to burst? No, but there will be correction. All nascent industries enjoy growth spurts and suffer growing pains and influencer marketing is no exception.” He also emphasized the role of PR in its evolution: “I think much of influencer marketing sits very neatly within our PR skillset as building mutually-beneficial long-term relationships is our bedrock skill.”

PR should be at the forefront of the influencer marketing redefinition, clearly separating it from influencer advertising’s transactional and short-sighted goals. Success should be defined through long-term and mutually beneficial relationship building rather than highly visible one-hit campaigns.

So, to answer our first question: no, influencer marketing isn’t dead, but it purposes need to be clarified. Being popular isn’t the same as being influential so best practise strategies should not only drive awareness but also result in actions and measurable outcomes. Something PR excels in.

About the Author

Jennifer Sanchis is a Senior Account Executive at PRIME Research in Oxford, UK and a frequent commentator on the public relations scene.This post first ran on Commpro.

You may also be interested in

The Big Deal About Big Data & PR

by Amanda Peterson Big data has become one of the most significant trends in modern technology. It’s no exaggeration to say that today’s society is generating massive amounts of information. In fact, studies have predicted that more than 90 percent of data in the world was created in the past two years. Such a wide scope of insight can be extremely useful across a range of industries, which is why many businesses are finding ways to take advantage of it. The field of public relations is no exception to the list of industries using big data to their advantage. Though PR is commonly recognized as a creative field, it is strongly supported by a backbone of research. Utilizing data is becoming increasingly important in PR because of its ability to improve campaign performance and generate ...

Learn more

Der CEO im politischen Spannungsfeld

In der anhaltenden Debatte um Zuwanderung und Integration halten sich die Manager der großen Unternehmen meist vornehm zurück. Wagt sich ein CEO aus der Deckung, kann er indes heftig in die Schusslinie geraten. Der Vorstandsvorsitzende der Siemens AG hat sich im vergangenen Frühjahr pointiert in die bis heute nicht abebbende Diskussion eingemischt. Er reagierte auf eine Äußerung der AfD-Vorsitzenden Alice Weidel, die im Deutschen Bundestag von "Kopftuchmädchen, Messermännern und anderen Nichtsnutzen" schwadronierte. Kaeser reagierte entschlossen und eindeutig in einem Tweet: "Lieber Kopftuchmädchen als Bund Deutscher Mädel." Für den Siemens-Chef war sein öffentlicher Beitrag eine "Herz- und Kopfentscheidung". Enorme Aufmerksamkeit Mit einigen wenigen Zeilen hat der Siemens-Chef ein ...

Learn more

What is Wrong with PR?

By Jennifer Sanchis This is probably PR’s greatest irony: PR suffers from bad reputation and image issues. Although the discipline has been institutionalised for years now, the industry is still facing an existential crisis that most practitioners and professional bodies are actively tackling. I wanted to look at the most crucial challenges and misconceptions which, according to me, are at the epicentre of “the PR problem”. PR shouldn’t be another one-way communication channel that organisations use to serve their own interests First published in 1999, the visionary authors of the highly impactful Cluetrain Manifesto were merciless when talking about PR’s credibility issue: “Everyone – including many PR people – senses that something is deeply phony about the profession […]. Take the ...

Learn more