North America

USA - New York

New York
New York
305 Madison Avenue
Suite 1850
New York, NY 10017
+1 212 981 1175
newyork@prime-research.com

USA - Detroit/ Ann Arbor

Ann Arbor / Detroit
Ann Arbor/ Detroit
309 Maynard Street
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
+1 734 913 0348
annarbor@prime-research.com

Europe

Germany

Frankfurt / Mainz
Kaiserstrasse 22
55116 Mainz
+49 6131 2180 0
mainz@prime-research.com

United Kingdom

Oxford
58 St. Aldates
Oxford, OX1 1ST
+44 1865 324 911
oxford@prime-research.com

Switzerland

Zurich
Seefeldstrasse 275
8008 Zurich
+41 43 488 53 5
zurich@prime-research.com

South America

Brazil

Sao Paulo
R. Verbo Divino, 1488
Sao Paulo, SP Brasil – 04719-904
+55 11 5180 4557
saopaulo@prime-research.com

Asia Pacific

China

Shanghai
Rm.306, Bldg. 2
Lujiazui Software Park No. 100, Lane 91, E'shan Rd. Pudong Shanghai 200127, China
+86 21 6859 2099
shanghai@prime-research.com

India

Office no. 3, 14th floor German Center
Building No. 9B -DLF Cyber City
Phase-III Gurgaon - INDIA
+91 124 463 6045
newdelhi@prime-research.com

How Media & Public Relations Researchers can Confront Fake News

Posted On December 12, 2016

Media chatter about fake news is nearly inescapable. The topic has dominated international news cycles following the American presidential election and continues to pop up in unexpected ways (see the Pizzagate incident). This recent impact of fake news has called the role and influence of mainstream media outlets further into question and is the latest headache for the gatekeepers of media and public relations.

While fake news isn’t anything, well, new, the growing social media amplification of active misinformation presents extra obstacles for media and PR practitioners. Online content reinforcing falsehoods subverts the media’s aim of mass information and public relations’ aim of mass persuasion.

Jonathan Albright, assistant professor of communications at Elon University, North Carolina, has emerged as an expert on this topic. His research has shown fake news sites are relying on methods of search engine optimization to strengthen their influence by linking to one another and mainstream news sources. Albright has also mapped a “vast satellite system that is encroaching on the mainstream news system.”

When compounded with trust in the media at an all-time low, media professionals and PR practitioners have their work cut out for them, but also have an opportunity to prove their value. Charlie Beckett, a journalist and LSE media professor, has suggested three solutions for media practitioners.

  1. News journalism must be explicit about whether the statements they report are evidence-based. “The excellent fact-checking that we are seeing has to be incorporated into the first paragraph and headlines, not just left for a side column or footnote.”
  2. Industry leaders need to leverage “algorithms, data-mining and network analysis like this to identify not just the sources of fake news such as those famous Macedonian teenagers, but also the way that platforms and other networks allow them to spread.”
  3. MSM needs to improve the level of transparency about its own work. It “should start to embrace what Frederic Filou calls the ‘signals of quality.’ The hope is that building a quality-scoring apparatus for news content can give a kind of embedded kitemark of editorial value.”

But all these solutions won’t cut false information from the media landscape – the internet is too vast and people tend to gravitate to content that confirms their views. The fragmentation of society along ideological lines poses one such challenge PR practitioners trying to reach a wide audience.

Robert Wynne of Wynne Communications said this fragmentation means the ‘end of mass persuasion’ for PR professionals and entrepreneurs using media to promote their products and services. “Because of the self-segregation by groups, each with its own beliefs and facts, we’ve entered a new era … the age of Micro-Persuasion or Tribal Persuasion.”

Communicators should then tailor their messages to different groups if not doing so already. Though more on the advertising side, the Trump campaign used Cambridge Analytica, a data mining company, to build psychological profiles representing some 230 million adult Americans based on Facebook data. Individually tailored digital ads were then tested and matched to these personality profiles.

No data point is informative on its own but access to tools to process a vast amount of data is one part of generating insights, such as knowing one’s audience. The other two parts require subject matter expertise, and critical thinking with applied statistics. These three aspects for insights will cut through the new obstacles fakes news presents.

About the Author

Kyle Wackrow manages client accounts and social media for PRIME Research. He tweets as @kyle_wackrow and can also be reached at wackrow@prime-research.com.

You may also be interested in

Strategy and Tactics: Finding a Balance through Research

It’s a curious thing how the overwhelming majority of public relations agencies and practitioners identify as “strategists.” Here’s the problem: if everyone is a strategist, how does anything get done? The natural inclination seems to be that “tactics are subordinate to strategy.” True, public relations is much more than just press conferences, interviews and publicity but it’s important to remember that the only way to accomplish our PR and business objectives is to bring strategy to life through tactical execution. As such, strategy and tactics are interrelated and equally essential for success. Communications research provides a foundation for the entire public relations process from landscape assessment to objective-setting to strategy development to tactical creativity and ...

Learn more

Overcoming Conventional Wisdom: Public Relations Must Demonstrate Value by Generating Value

By Mark Weiner, Chief Executive Officer, PRIME Research As the reputation of public relations within corporations continues to grow, we face an increased need to generate a positive return on investment as well as a satisfactory return on expectation. Unlike our everyday challenges with journalists, analysts and opinion-leaders, these challenges originate with our internal clients. Top executives keep public relations budgets low while maintaining high expectations. In this way, public relations falls victim to the conventional business wisdom that PR hasn’t earned more resources because it cannot be measured. New Challenges for Marketing and Public Relations While the stigma has improved over time thanks to the good works of the Institute for Public Relations, AMEC and their members, ...

Learn more

Is 2017 the Year for Clean-Slate PR? The Need for Better Objectives.

The Need for Fresh Thinking in Public Relations As we prepare for the New Year, it’s time to think about starting over. Yes, completely and thoroughly. If you don't know the degree to which your corporate communications program delivered value, met expectations and succeeded in generating a positive return, it’s probably because you began the year without knowing your clients' priorities, the degree to which PR delivers what they value and how best to communicate results. And even if you measure your public relations, without a clear sense of why you measure, you may need to break with the past and start anew. That’s what we call “clean slate public relations.” Clean slate public relations is a layering process that begins and ends with research. It provides a fresh beginning to reexamine ...

Learn more